Specter jumps ship. Ship doesn't know it's sinking

Pennsylvania Sen. Arlen Specter is either a great statesman or the most unprincipled politician who ever lived, depending on what editorial you are reading.

But whatever he is, and the truth is probably a little bit of both, his decision to leave the Republican Party and join the Democrats is less importantly about him and more about the party he forsakes.

Will the last moderate Republican please close the door? Once upon a time, liberal Republicans were a visible presence and a civilizing influence on the party. The dominate right-wing ideologues have pretty much hunted the moderates to extinction. As much as they rail against Specter for leaving, it was they who made his enduring presence intolerable. It was either leave or be kicked out and he chose to leave.

(Full disclosure: I am a liberal still registered as a Republican, although in truth I have always thought party labels pretty much ridiculous. Still, I am thinking of applying for protection under the Endangered Species Act).

This long-term vendetta against liberals and moderates is an act of political suicide by what Specter himself has called the party's cannibals - those wild-eyed folks who like to feed on their own. Their obsession does not change a political fact of life: The party that holds the middle political ground has the better shot of winning everywhere with a few exceptions, mostly in the South.

But the right-wingers would rather be right than bright. Too bad - because what is good for the Democrats isn't necessarily good for America. Someone has to keep the Democrats honest and the party that can do it is fast going down the drain hole of history, all soaped up and steaming in its quest for purity.

 


Posted Apr 28 2009, 07:13 PM by Reg Henry

Comments

WaltDaddy wrote re: Specter jumps ship. Ship doesn't know it's sinking
on Wed, Apr 29 2009 10:18 AM

Mr. Henry,

I am a conservative Republican. I am thrilled that Senator Spector has decided to leave.

Democrats are known for shunning individuals who don't toe the party line. Remember when Governor Casey was denied a forum to speak at the 1992 Democratic convention because he dared to be Pro-Life? He was a moderate Democrat who was abandoned by his party. Where was the uproar among the tolerant liberals then?

If we are supposed to embrace pro-abortion, anti-gun, big spending liberals in the Republican party, what is there to differentiate us from the Democrats? We are a political party, not a gang. What "set you claim" is far less important than how you think or how you vote.

Mermaid wrote re: Specter jumps ship. Ship doesn't know it's sinking
on Wed, Apr 29 2009 1:42 PM

Specter is an opportunist, to be sure, but he hasn't changed positions that much over the years.  The GOP has, however.  It's drifted rightward, leaving a vacuum in the center that the Democrats are successfully filling.  

It's interesting that WaltDaddy brings up Bob Casey Sr.'s shunning at the 1992 convention.  The Democrats eventually learned from this mistake and made an effort to attract a wider range of candidates.  The Republicans were pretty good about being inclusive for a while, but then began repeating the Democratic Party's old mistake of insisting on ideological purity in their candidates.    The result was the election of a number of conservative and centrist Democrats during the past  couple of cycles, including Bob Casey Jr.  Many of these candidates would have (and in some cases, did) run as Republicans in past years, but did not pass the party's current ideological litmus tests.  Specter's departure from his party is part and parcel of this shift.  It's certainly fueled by naked ambition, but it makes sense given the rightward swing of the GOP, its closed primary, and its declining numbers in Pennsylvania.

Titan Lee wrote re: Specter jumps ship. Ship doesn't know it's sinking
on Wed, Apr 29 2009 5:36 PM

"But the right-wingers would rather be right than bright. "

What a damning statement.  I agree.  The Republicans should wake up and realize that getting elected is what matters.  Principles are not important.  Elections are.

Obama, Reid, Pelosi, Schumer, Specter, Dodd, Frank, etc, etc, etc.  I guess that's your definition of "bright".

WaltDaddy wrote re: Specter jumps ship. Ship doesn't know it's sinking
on Thu, Apr 30 2009 9:57 AM

Mermaid:

Ideas and principles are more important to me than Party. I'm a Republican, but I'm happy to have Bob Casey Jr. as my Senator. He's a decent man. He's a Conservative. He just happens to be a Democrat.

It illustrates a point. In order for Democrats to win, they had to Field more Republican-like candidates.