A Fine Point

Authors

The editors who craft the Post-Gazette’s daily stands on the issues affecting the region, the state and the nation hold an on-line conversation with readers about key topics in the news. The PG editorial writers are: Tom Waseleski, Reg Henry, Susan Mannella, Tony Norman and Dan Simpson.  

 Register to comment
Guide to commenting

Syndication

H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine

It's a good thing that no one from modern Wall Street was on the Titanic when it slammed into the iceberg. As the freezing waters rose, the women and children would have had to line up behind the most well-connected firms in the country for a place in the lifeboats.

Nothing symbolizes the fiasco that has been the distribution of the H1N1 vaccine better than news that Wall Street firms like Citigroup and Goldman Sachs are receiving supplies of the vaccine before the rest of the public.

You don't have to be a populist to be disgusted by the news. One would have expected preferential treatment of the powerful and connected during the Bush years, but the fact that this is happening during President Barack Obama's watch is beyond galling.

How did we get to the point where Wall Street employers have access to a precious health commodity before ordinary citizens in at-risk groups -- or the general public?

In anticipation of a swine flu outbreak, the government ordered 250 million doses of the vaccine. Because of manufacturing delays and unrealistic promises by the pharmaceutical industry, only 32 million doses are available. More vaccines are entering the pipeline every day, but the shortage has created a larger-than-expected demand in all regions of the country.

For its part, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has designated children, young people under 24, pregnant women, caretakers for children under 6 months, those ages 25 to 64 with chronic health conditions and health-care workers as the most at-risk. The states are responsible for distributing the H1N1 vaccine to these at-risk citizens.

Every day on the news, long lines of Americans of all sorts wait for flu shots at clinics and malls. Some have waited all night. Others have sacrificed large chunks of their workday, only to be told that the allotted supplies have been exhausted. This is infuriating and an outrage.

New York health officials are letting businesses with onsite medical staff request supplies of the vaccine, but they must agree to give it only to employees in high-risk groups. We have to wonder how many thousands of pregnant women, infants or elderly are on the payrolls of Goldman Sachs, Citigroup, the Federal Reserve Bank, Time Inc., Columbia University and other big New York employers that have received the vaccine.

The government shouldn't have made it available to these employers ahead of the rest of the country in the first place.

The fact that the Obama administration has not been able to deliver the vaccine to all who want it -- in November already -- is a travesty. It shakes our confidence in the president's ability to succeed with a much larger government initiative -- the public option in health-care reform.

  


Posted Nov 09 2009, 05:00 AM by Susan Mannella

Comments

mugsy wrote re: H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine
on Mon, Nov 9 2009 8:55 AM

"It shakes our confidence in the president's ability to succeed with a much larger government initiative -- the public option in health-care reform."

Well, that was a pointed, insightful and surprising observation coming from the PG editorialist. I may have to rethink my vast left-wing conspiracy theory.

my opinion wrote re: H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine
on Mon, Nov 9 2009 9:11 AM

You don't have to be a populist to be disgusted by the news. One would have expected preferential treatment of the powerful and connected during the Bush years, but the fact that this is happening during President Barack Obama's watch is beyond galling.

You can expect it from President Bush all you want, but you got it from President Obama.

How did we get to the point where Wall Street employers have access to a precious health commodity before ordinary citizens in at-risk groups -- or the general public

Not sure why Wall Street employers are not a part of the general public.

I agree, this is one of the most surprising editorials from the P-G.  We can say good-bye to that writer.

Titan Lee wrote re: H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine
on Mon, Nov 9 2009 9:23 AM

Is today April Fool's Day?

chilco99 wrote re: H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine
on Mon, Nov 9 2009 11:43 AM

Oh ye of Hope & Change blinded by the empty words of the false prophet............... WAKE UP! Wall Street elected this clown and puppet on a string named Barack hussein Obama. You'll get niether a crumb of bread nor a flu shot from this empty Charlie McCarthy ventriloquist.

kevin morris wrote re: H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine
on Mon, Nov 9 2009 12:50 PM

As a knee jerk liberal this is when I'm supposed to threaten to stop my subscription, but I only read the paper on the net.

Hey, Ruth Ann busted corporate chops last week. Maybe they are trying to be more fair and balanced-funny how that phrase is only used ironically now.

myreply wrote re: H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine
on Mon, Nov 9 2009 3:40 PM

Yet another thing for you all to get teed off about, so you don't worry about the things that are really important. This admin. is good!  They sure know how to pull your strings.

The flu season will be over before all the vaccine is delivered - so why the big deal.

my opinion wrote re: H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine
on Wed, Nov 11 2009 9:49 AM

myreply

Your right, why the big deal. I didn't get it when this same thing happened (to a lesser degree) under President Bush. The left went crazy over how mismanaged it was.  Same thing here, not done.  Of course this time none of this will be President Obama fault.  

Kevin

Maybe they are trying to be more fair and balanced-funny how that phrase is only used ironically now.

It is only used ironically by you.  For you to have fair and balanced in the same sentence must have taken several minutes to get the courage to type, let alone actually being F & B.

chilco99 wrote re: H1N1 fiasco: It's time all Americans had access to the vaccine
on Thu, Nov 12 2009 8:10 AM

I have taken disaster and emergency continuing education courses and the first rule of thumb is to cut off  and contain a viral pathogen.

It's ironic how a 3rd world country like Mexico was able to do that, and how the United States government failed so miserably or ignored the problem all in favor of commerce and trade.

Shame on you Barack Obama, Janet Napolitano, and Kethleen Sabelius.