A Fine Point

Authors

The editors who craft the Post-Gazette’s daily stands on the issues affecting the region, the state and the nation hold an on-line conversation with readers about key topics in the news. The PG editorial writers are: Tom Waseleski, Reg Henry, Susan Mannella, Tony Norman and Dan Simpson.  

 Register to comment
Guide to commenting

Syndication

Home casualties: The Fort Hood tragedy begs for answers

The killing of at least 13 people in the heart of America's military network in Fort Hood, Texas, is very hard to bear.

Losses in the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, now surpassing 5,000, are deaths also, endured and grieved by families, friends and citizens. But Thursday's events, occurring in what passes for home for hundreds of thousands of U.S. troops and their families, is sharply inflicted pain.

Making sense of what happened -- if that is possible -- will take time and require further knowledge of the apparent killer and the circumstances that led to this disaster. It will not help the country that Maj. Malik Nidal Hasan, the person who likely will be charged with the killings, is apparently a fervent Muslim, with family roots in the Middle East, the locus of the two wars and the scene of some of the most severe violence that has afflicted the world for the last six decades.

Another factor to examine in trying to understand what happened is the degree to which members of America's professional army have been stressed and stretched by a six-year war in Iraq and an eight-year war in Afghanistan. Soldiers have been sent on repeated tours of duty in difficult, hostile circumstances with only brief respites at home between deployments.

This overuse of the volunteer military is due to the fact that the nation's elected leaders know Americans would not tolerate a draft to supply troops for the two wars.

While Maj. Hasan had not served in Iraq or Afghanistan and was deeply opposed to the U.S. role there, he was on the eve of his first deployment -- to Afghanistan. As an Army psychiatrist, he worked for six years, until last July, as a liaison between wounded soldiers and psychiatric staff at Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington, D.C. He heard their stories and was well acquainted with their pain.

There is no justification, however, for the injury and death that he apparently perpetrated, and his family was right to denounce the act as "despicable and deplorable."

There is no point in criticizing Fort Hood. It is considered to be a model of a military base. At the same time, Killeen, Texas, where it is located, is a typical military town, with streets of payroll loan, pawn and gun shops serving a largely transient, not well-paid population.

At this point, Americans can only regret what happened at Fort Hood and grieve for those lost and their loved ones.

 


Posted Nov 07 2009, 05:00 AM by Susan Mannella

Comments

myreply wrote re: Home casualties: The Fort Hood tragedy begs for answers
on Sat, Nov 7 2009 7:42 AM

Why are there questions?

There are no questions.  There is no reason this should have happened, just like there is no reason why any killing of innocents should happen.  

Just another nut that took his resentment out on others because he was too much a coward to end his own miserable life.  He's on a ventilator - I hope his life ends soon.

kevin morris wrote re: Home casualties: The Fort Hood tragedy begs for answers
on Sat, Nov 7 2009 9:14 AM

My reply, we always want to know why something happened. And, respectfully, there are always reasons for a person's actions, although sometimes the reasons are more tied to the inside of their head than what is going on outside it.

You are totally right that there is no justification for his actions, and also right that it would have been better if he had just pointed the gun at his own head.

brooklineusa wrote re: Home casualties: The Fort Hood tragedy begs for answers
on Sat, Nov 7 2009 10:28 AM

He was deeply oppose to the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. Yet, he had no problem letting the U.S. Military pay for medical school. Tell the truth PG, if a white guy had shot up a mosque, you certainly would not be this sympathetic in your editiorial. Just another example of the hypocrisy you espouse. I do find it a bit embarassing that this clown could shot dozens of people on a army base, and what stopped his rampage was a female civilian police officer. He would have never made it that far on a marine installation.

kevin morris wrote re: Home casualties: The Fort Hood tragedy begs for answers
on Sat, Nov 7 2009 4:04 PM

Brookline, I didn't detect any excess of sympathy for the perpetrator in this column, just an effort to try to figure out why it may have happened.

I did think it was disingenuous to bring up how our forces have been stressed and stretched as a possible factor in his actions; he has never been deployed before, so this just does not apply to him.  

my opinion wrote re: Home casualties: The Fort Hood tragedy begs for answers
on Sat, Nov 7 2009 6:14 PM

Things are starting to come out about this guy and although early and I am speculating, I believe we will see that this could have been avoided except those that could have affected the outcome were PC when they should have taken action years ago.

chilco99 wrote re: Home casualties: The Fort Hood tragedy begs for answers
on Sat, Nov 7 2009 7:58 PM

Let's all just hold hands and reiterate what president(s) Bush & Obama told us: "Islam is a religion of peace:)"