A Fine Point

Authors

The editors who craft the Post-Gazette’s daily stands on the issues affecting the region, the state and the nation hold an on-line conversation with readers about key topics in the news. The PG editorial writers are: Tom Waseleski, Reg Henry, Susan Mannella, Tony Norman and Dan Simpson.  

 Register to comment
Guide to commenting

Syndication

The socialism of John McCain

Tom Waseleski

Short on cash and out of ideas, John McCain is going around the country trying to scare voters into believing that Barack Obama is .... a Muslim? a terrorist? No, worse than that -- a socialist. He's faulting Obama for allegedly wanting to transfer wealth and income from hard-working Americans to some unnamed, phantom, you-fill-in-the-blank recipients. In reality, given McCain's longer tenure in the Senate, he has been a "socialist" far longer than Obama.

What do you call taking taxpayer money and spending them on veterans' benefits? An income transfer. Where do the Social Security taxes I pay go? Not to me, but to retired Americans -- another income transfer. Most workers haven't seen a dollar in Medicare benefits, but we all help to pay for the program and hope that it's there when we need its health coverage. That's taking money from one group and sending it to another. The fact that John McCain has never sought to eliminate these wealth transfers during his decades in Washington shows him to be a bigger "socialist" than Barack Obama.

All mature Americans who want a fair and civil society can thank McCain and the rest of Congress for that. But he's not about to sacrifice a political catch phrase for the truth. It's like McCain's bumble-speak yesterday at Robert Morris University. He made a veiled reference to John Murtha's remark about racism in Western Pennsylvania, then botched his punch line by misstating: "I couldn't agree with him more."  Sure, Barack Obama believes in income transfers and John McCain couldn't agree more.


Posted Oct 22 2008, 07:20 AM by Tom Waseleski

Comments

Toadsly wrote re: The socialism of John McCain
on Thu, Oct 23 2008 11:34 AM

The Fabian socialists, who were instrumental in developing the modern concept of state-socialism and eschewed Marxism in favor capitalism, held that political activists are either anarchists or bureaucrats.

Mr. Waseleski's contention that both McCain and Obama are socialists is a valid point since they are not anarchists and both serve us in a democracy that practices bureaucratic collectivism.