The Oakland arrests

After two long days of G-20 protest coverage, I was mentally depleted. But as the situation escalated in Oakland last night, I felt like I had no choice but to check it out. I was receiving texts and phone calls from several reporters we had at the scene. It sounded as though there was going to be a mass police action against the protesters gathered at Schenley Plaza.

When I arrived, there were more riot police in one place than I had seen all week. They had already forced the protesters out of Schenley Plaza and onto Forbes Avenue. They kept lining up officers, pushing us further and further up Forbes until a van sped up from the Craig Street direction. Another group of riot cops got out of the van and aggressively kept the crowd from moving in any direction other than onto the Cathedral of Learning lawn. Until then, I was with Post-Gazette reporter Sadie Gurman. As the police cornered us, I realized for the first time during this summit that I didn't have an out other than going through the police line. While journalists are usually not targets for police during these riots, we still aren't afforded any special legal protection. I turned to see that I had lost Sadie. I figured I was either going to get out, or be arrested right there and then. I slowly walked at the officers, hands raised, yelling "I'm press! I just want out!"

They let me through their lines. I sighed relief.

As they encircled the Cathedral lawn, I made my way to Fifth Avenue. As I walked, I noticed two men supporting a third man, carrying him to a set of concrete steps on Fifth. As I got closer, I realized the three were friends of mine. Pittsburgh Tribune-Review photographers Justin Merriman and Andrew Russell were aiding Tribune-Review photographer Guy Wathen after he had been maced on the lawn.

After they set him down, they poured water over his face and put saline solution into his eyes, but to no avail. Wathen had been trapped on the lawn with Merriman and Russell, trying to walk away from police when an officer maced him. He was almost completely incapacitated. After five minutes, it became clear the water wasn't helping, and the Trib photographers again helped Wathen move to a car to be taken to the hospital.

After they drove off, I was stuck rather far away from any of the things I'd have wanted to photograph. The police weren't letting anyone by, and anyone that got close was likely to have a smoke grenade lobbed at them. Emotionally drained, I tried to call Sadie to see if she had gotten out, but the phone call went to her voicemail. I called another reporter we had at the scene, Moriah Balingit, and realized neither of us knew where Sadie was.

She had been arrested.

I left the scene emotionally exhausted.


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Michael Henninger/Post-Gazette View larger version

 


Posted Sep 26 2009, 06:25 PM by Michael Henninger

Comments

JD13 wrote re: The Oakland arrests
on Sat, Sep 26 2009 7:02 PM

I have a hard time feeling sorry for any of these "students" or reporters who feel the need to be in the middle of the action for no other reason than to be there. You act surprised that your friend gets pepper sprayed or your collegue gets arrested. You get what you get. The police did there job, and did it well.

Instone30 wrote re: The Oakland arrests
on Sat, Sep 26 2009 9:34 PM

The police did do their job dispersing an illegal or unauthorized assembly (?) of people, but journalists are there as a necessary part of our society.  Anyone that thinks every single cop is of the highest ethical moral fiber is kidding themselves.  I know some who were "joking" about getting the chance to beat down some protesters.  I mean really, they have a tough job and that fact should be respected, but they're not all saints.

On a side note, is this called Eyes on Fire because on of the photographers got maced?  That's one of the silliest headlines I've ever read.  

Edited to note that it seems to be the column name.  Seriously?

Michael Henninger wrote re: The Oakland arrests
on Sun, Sep 27 2009 1:01 AM

Eyes on Fire is a reference to the start of my career (check out the first posting on the blog).  It's the name of the blog, not the posting.  And I don't disagree that the Police were out doing their job last night.  We were out doing our job too.  If we all stayed away when it got a little dangerous, we wouldn't be witness to what's actually happening.  I was out there too, no different than the photographer who was maced, and these photographs are the result.  

JD13 wrote re: The Oakland arrests
on Sun, Sep 27 2009 10:35 AM

Reporters do have a job to do, I agree. But in this age of sensationalism and 24/7 in your face coverage, I think it's pretty rediculous that a reporter or photographer has to be right in the *** and then whine, (not you particularly Michael) and project themselves as some type of collateral damage in a protest, like the CNN reporter that got a dose of CS gas. If a crowd is told to disperse, and they are part of that crowd, it's not the Police job at that time to tell the difference between "press" and some anarchist toting a camera, nor should it be. I think it becomes a contest amongst reporters at some point to tell a story, much like these idiots down south during the floods who have to put themselves in the most pecarious position to show me that they're in a flood because I can't see for myself that they're surrounded by water.

JD13 wrote re: The Oakland arrests
on Sun, Sep 27 2009 10:43 AM

And as you reported in this blog...water will not help when sprayed by pepper spray...lol. As for Instone's post...True, there are some bad apples in the law enforcement community as well as other professions, and I'm sure there was more than one joke told about knocking heads with protesters, much like many of the anarchist I"m sure made jokes about the "pigs". However, I think the law enforcement community as a whole was very professional in their handling of this summit. I think they showed great restraint in how they handled the Oakland incidents as well. And for anyone who complained that there was too much police presence, I'd rather too much than not enough. You meet force not with equal force, but with greater and overwhelming force. The end result...less injury to all, and a City that is still recognizable the following week.