Blog 'n' Gold

Author

P-G sports online editor Dan Gigler blogs about the Steelers.

Register to comment
Guide to commenting

Syndication

Blogs of Steel

AFC North coverage

2009 opponents' coverage

Steelers Nation Video Postcards

Steelers fan video features

Trip to Canton, pt. 1.

Have been on staycation recently and decided to take a drive to Canton, to see the Pro Football Hall of Fame. I hadn't been there in more than 20 years and remembered little of it.

Just about two hours outside of Pittsburgh its an easy drive to make, but I'd stop short of calling it an absolute must-see. Although interesting, I expected to be overwhelmed with voluminous amounts of memorabilia, artifacts, photographs, interactive exhibits and written narration from the 117-year history of pro football and 89 years of the NFL, that might take an entire day (or even two) to get through. There is a lot of cool stuff, but overall it was a bit paltry based not only on my expectations, but also the ungodly wealth, power and popularity that the NFL wields. I expected a little more.  

By comparison, for instance, the Steelers 75th Anniversary exhibit at the Heinz History Center's Western Pennsylvania Sports Museum (done in conjunction with the Hall) a few years ago was much more detailed and artifact-laden, though on a much smaller scale. My friend and I easily breezed through the HOF in 3 hours, and that was while taking a lot of time to look at everything. For Steelers fans, the $18 price of admission is justified by the 24-minute "Road to the Super Bowl (XLIII)" highlight film currently being shown in the GameDay Stadium on a massive Cinemascope screen with stadium seating.

Again, I'm not at all saying that its not worth going to at some point -- it is, and there are certainly worse ways to spend a day -- but I also wouldn't put it on the absolute-must-do-before-I-die-Bucket List either.

008

The first professional player, William "Pudge" Heffelfinger was paid $500 by the Allegheny Athletic Association (in Pittsburgh) for his services in 1892.

006

The AAA's balance sheet that indicates payment to Heffelfinger. 

018

The oldest football in the Hall's collection.  

020

My new Facebook profile pic. That's Lawson Fiscus of the AAA.  

027

Canton Bulldogs jersey, circa 1920s. 

002

One thing I've often wondered is that given Southwestern Pennsylvania's role as the cradle of pro football and that the first professional game, player and team were in Pittsburgh, why the Hall isn't here? Well, as you can read above, the answer is simple: Canton (also with major early pro football bona fides) lobbied hard and put up money for it.  

031

The Pottsville Maroons -- rightful champions in 1925.

029

See explanation above.

026

Loose basis for the film Leatherheads.

024

 Old shoulder pads.

044

The actual "Hall" itself has a dramatic presentaion. The wall-mounted bronze busts of the enshrinees are underlit, giving it a truly hallowed aura. They are displayed in chronological order, and kiosks in the middle provide all manner of biogrpahical information as well as video highlights and retrospectives of each member. 

063

The inspiration for the name "Super Bowl." Seriously. Lamar Hunt was watching his kids play with one and got the idea for the name.

073

Ticket to the first Super Bowl. I happen to have met a guy who was at that one, and every one since and correctly picked the exact final score of Super Bowl XLIII.

077

Will this guy join six of his pals in Pittsburgh come February? Stay tuned ...


Posted Oct 27 2009, 04:59 PM by Dan Gigler

Comments

JL wrote re: Trip to Canton, pt. 1.
on Wed, Oct 28 2009 1:50 AM

We live out west, so I've only been to Canton once. But it was during the summer of '07, en route to training camp in Latrobe. The Steelers 75th Anniversary Exhibit was there, in the Hall of Fame. I don't know who was more thrilled to be there, me, or my then 8 year old-son, who had heard all the stories from me. Now, right before our eyes, were the shoes Franco wore while making the Immaculate Reception, a Jerome Bettis' jersey, the actual Lombardi trophies -man, remembering it all still sends tingles down my spine!. All the other aritifacts, photos, and interesting history on display about the rest of the NFL was pretty cool too. I guess that in my opinion, the quaintness and the almost palpability of so many of the pieces of legendary history right before you, is what makes Canton special. As they say, different strokes...

Dan Gigler wrote re: Trip to Canton, pt. 1.
on Wed, Oct 28 2009 2:05 AM

Good points all, JL, and good to hear from you.

Again, I didn't say that it was bad, just that I expected more of everything. More artifacts, more details, etc. The memorabilia that was there was very neat and interesting, but I just expected not only more of it, but also more lengthy explanations of it all. For instance, the picture of the oldest ball in the Hall's collection -- unless I missed it, no details on where it came from, how it was acquired, how it was made -- same with the old helmets and equipment.

I've not been to the museums at Cooperstown, Springfield, Toronto or South Bend, so my only basis for comparison was the Steelers exhibit at the Heinz Museum and the Great Hall at Heinz Field.

I guess I just expected to be completely bowled over, and I wasn't, nor was my traveling partner (a Vikes fan visiting for the game). We liked it, just didn't come away completely blown away, which is kind of what we expected.

Perhaps I should amend the text in the post to better stress that point.

Twitter Trackbacks for Trip to Canton, pt. 1. - Blog 'n' Gold - post-gazette.com [post-gazette.com] on Topsy.com wrote Twitter Trackbacks for Trip to Canton, pt. 1. - Blog 'n' Gold - post-gazette.com [post-gazette.com] on Topsy.com
on Wed, Oct 28 2009 4:10 AM

Pingback from  Twitter Trackbacks for                 Trip to Canton, pt. 1. - Blog 'n' Gold - post-gazette.com         [post-gazette.com]        on Topsy.com

uberVU - social comments wrote Social comments and analytics for this post
on Wed, Oct 28 2009 7:06 AM

This post was mentioned on Twitter by Steelersdepot: Post Gazette Blog: Trip to Canton, pt. 1. http://bit.ly/ovg2J #steelers #nfl

JL wrote re: Trip to Canton, pt. 1.
on Wed, Oct 28 2009 10:14 PM

Surely, if the Steelers' exhibit hadn't been there, our experience would not have been the same. We were truly lucky to visit during the Hall's celebration of the Steelers' 75th. And once again, your photos are absolutely fantastic, Dan.

Blog 'n' Gold wrote Canton trip: leftovers
on Fri, Oct 30 2009 1:06 AM

Last batch of pics from the excursion to Canton. If you missed it, check out Part One and Part Two (all

sringst wrote re: Trip to Canton, pt. 1.
on Sat, Oct 31 2009 1:12 PM

Dan,

From what I've read, Art Rooney Sr. was fully backing the construction of the HOF in Latrobe, but once proof of the first pro game in Pittsburgh came to light, he backed off and no longer supported the Latrobe bid.  Once that happened, the Canton contingent saw their chance and pushed hard for it there.